1971 Champions
- Pentathalon: Robert Reider (Ohio University)
- Team: Ohio University
1972 Champions
- Pentathalon: Jim Molnar (Ohio University)
- Team: Ball State University
1973 Champions
- Pentathalon: David Beal (Ohio University)
- Team: Eastern Michigan University
- Founder's Trophy: Ohio University
1974 Champions
- Pentathalon: Bobbi Rowe (Stetson University)
- Team: Ohio University
- Founder's Trophy: Eastern Michigan University
1975 Champions
- Pentathalon: Bobbi Rowe (Stetson University)
- Team: Ohio University
- Founder's Trophy: Ball State University
1976 Champions
- Pentathalon: Irene Ziegler (Stetson University)
- Team: Eastern Michigan University
- Founder's Trophy: Ohio University
1977 Champions
- Pentathalon: Michael Garcia (Eastern Michigan University)
- Team: Eastern Michigan University
- Founder's Trophy: Eastern Michigan University
1978 Champions
- Pentathalon: William Allen Young (University of Southern California)
- Team: Eastern Michigan University
- Founder's Trophy: George Mason University
1979 Champions
- Pentathalon: George Denger (Eastern Michigan University)
- Team: Eastern Michigan University
- Founder's Trophy: Stetson University