1990 Champions
- Pentathalon: Stephanie Kaplan (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Arizona State University
- Team (Division II): Ohio University
- Team (Division III): University of Indianapolis
- Founder's Trophy: Eastern Michigan University
1991 Champions
- Pentathalon: Karon Bowers (Bradley University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Ohio State University
- Team (Division II): Southeastern Illinois College
- Team (Division III): Cedarville University
- Founder's Trophy: Illinois State University
1992 Champions
- Pentathalon: Ronnie Stewart (Bradley University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Hastings College
- Team (Division II): University of Nebraska-Lincoln
- Team (Division III): Carleton College
- Founder's Trophy: Bradley University
1993 Champions
- Pentathalon: Jason Berke (Illinois State University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Arizona State University
- Team (Division II): University of Wisconsin-Madison
- Team (Division III):
- Founder's Trophy: Ball State University
1994 Champions
- Pentathalon: Andy Wood (Berry)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I):
- Team (Division II):
- Team (Division III):
- Founder's Trophy: University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire
1995 Champions
- Pentathalon: Jason Berke (Illinois State University)
- Team (Open Division): Illinois State University
- Team (Division I):
- Team (Division II):
- Team (Division III):
- Founder's Trophy: Miami University (Ohio)
1996 Champions
- Pentathalon: August Benassi (Bradley University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Western Kentucky University
- Team (Division II): University of Nebraska-Lincoln
- Team (Division III): University of Colorado
- Founder's Trophy: Oakland University
1997 Champions
- Pentathalon: Chris Grove (Illinois State University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Saint Joseph's University
- Team (Division II):
- Team (Division III):
- Founder's Trophy: Arizona State University
1998 Champions
- Pentathalon: tie between Brendan Kelly (Eastern Michigan University); Grant Ward (Illinois State University)
- Team (Open Division): Bradley University
- Team (Division I): Saint Joseph's University
- Team (Division II): Wayne State University
- Team (Division III): University of Illinois
- Founder's Trophy: Bradley University
1999 Champions
- Pentathalon: Brian Davis (Arizona State University)
- Team (Open Division): Illinois State University
- Team (Division I): Miami University
- Team (Division II): University of the Pacific
- Team (Division III): Glendale Community College
- Founder's Trophy: Eastern Michigan University